DailyTrackly

Guides Call tracking

Call tracking

Insurance agency call tracking: which lead sources pay off

Every lead company, ad, and mailer says its calls are worth it. Call tracking tells you which ones actually turn into quotes and policies, so you spend more where it works and stop where it doesn't.

Every plan is free for 7 days. No contract.

Updated October 30, 2026 · 4 min read · By the DailyTrackly team

What call tracking is

Call tracking means knowing where each call came from and what happened after it. For an agency, the question behind it is simple: for every dollar you spend on leads, how many policies did you write?

The usual way is a separate phone number for each source. Calls to the number you gave a lead company are that company's calls, so you can count them, answer them, and follow them to a quote or a sale.

Give each source its own number

  • One number per lead company that sends calls or live transfers.
  • One number per campaign you want to judge on its own: a mailer, a billboard, a search ad.
  • Your main number for everything else: referrals, customers, and people who found you.
  • Save the source on the lead too, for leads that come in by form, list, or referral.
In DailyTrackly

Your first local number is included with your plan, and more are $5 once, then $4 a month, so a number for each source costs little. Name each one in Settings → Phone, and it rings the ring group or agent you choose.

What to measure for each source

MeasureWhat it tells you
Calls inHow much the source sends
Answered and missedWhether your team is there when it rings
Talk time and average callWhether the callers are real prospects
QuotedHow many callers got a quote afterwards
Sold and premiumWhat the source is worth
Cost per saleWhat you paid the source, divided by policies sold

Count each caller once, and give the quote or sale to the call that came before it. A source with lots of short calls and few quotes is sending you the wrong people, however cheap each call is.

Don't let calls go unanswered

A missed call from a paid source is money spent on nothing. Watch the answer rate by source and by hour, and fix the gaps: a ring group that rings more agents, a queue when everyone's busy, or someone who answers after hours.

In DailyTrackly

Callers wait in line when every agent is busy, and any free agent picks them up with one click. Tracy, the AI Agent, can answer when nobody's free or the office is closed.

Live transfers: hold the lead company to its numbers

Live transfer companies usually bill by call length. Track the same lengths they bill by, and share the results with them, so you only argue about calls that really were short.

  • Missed: nobody answered.
  • Dropped: answered, then over within seconds.
  • Billable: talked at least the length in your contract, such as 90 seconds or 2 minutes.
  • Quoted and sold: what came of the call, so the company knows which calls work.
In DailyTrackly

Each number's transfer results count missed, dropped, and billable calls at the lengths you pick, with how many were quoted and sold, and you can share them with the lead company. When the carrier issues a policy, an admin can mark it Issued, and the results say so.

How call tracking works in DailyTrackly

  1. Give each source its own number in Settings → Phone.
  2. Calls & Text → Sources lists every number with its calls in, answered, missed, talk time, and average call.
  3. Pick the columns after those: callers quoted and sold after their call, the premium of the sales, and any status, such as Pending Sale.
  4. Switch to By lead source to see the source saved on each lead, for calls both ways.

Every call is recorded and saved on the lead, and admins get last week's calls by source by email every Monday. Sources is for admins: agents don't see it. Plans start at $19 per agent a month with 1,000 minutes per agent. See the phone system or compare plans.

One seat, one price.

Bought separately, a phone system, a dialer, a CRM, a texting tool, and AI call coaching typically list around $215 per agent a month. DailyTrackly is one $19 seat. Pro includes 1,000 texts and 1,000 minutes per agent. The admin login is free for managing the workspace; an admin who also calls or texts uses a seat.

$19 per agent a month · no contract See plans and prices →

Call tracking

Common questions

What is call tracking for insurance agencies?

Knowing which lead source each call came from and what happened after it: answered or missed, quoted, sold, and the premium, so you can see what each source is worth.

How do I track calls from different lead sources?

Give each source its own phone number, so every call to that number is that source's call, and save the source on leads that come in by form or list.

Can DailyTrackly track live transfers?

Yes. Each number's transfer results count missed, dropped, and billable calls at the lengths you pick, with how many were quoted and sold, and you can share them with the lead company.

From $19 per agent a month

Know which leads pay for themselves.

Every plan is free for 7 days. No contract.

Rather talk now? Call (502) 289-8495 or text us

Book a demo